How To Answer "Decision Making" Interview Questions
When an interviewer asks you to walk them through a big call you made without enough data, they want to hear how you handle uncertainty, not how you made an unexpectedly good call. Tell it in 3 parts: what you didn’t know, why you decided to move forward anyway, and what evidence would have reversed your decision, with the backup plan.
What goes wrong with the “trusted my gut” answer?
Exec interview, and they ask:
“Walk me through a big call you made without enough data.”
“Sound decisive. Leaders are decisive.”
So you pick the time you had a hunch and went for it.
Clean arc. Confident ending.
(For a story about missing data, it went suspiciously smoothly.)
Everybody has a “trusted my gut and it worked” story.
It sounds rehearsed, or reckless.
What do interviewers want to hear in decision making interview questions?
What they want to hear is how you handle uncertainty, not how you made an unexpectedly good call.
How do you tell a decision story in 3 parts?
Tell it in 3 parts:
- What you didn’t know and what hinged on that information.
- Why you decided to move forward anyway. You probably thought risk A was smaller than risk B.
- What evidence would have reversed your decision, and what the backup plan was, if needed.
This is the kind of answer I help leaders prep before their interviews.
What makes a decision story sound like leadership instead of luck?
A decision with no doubt in it sounds like luck.
A decision with doubt and a backup plan sounds like sober leadership.
If you’re a leader with exec interviews coming up, and your decision stories sound sure but land flat, this is what I help you prep:

