Employee Asking for a Raise You Can't Approve? Don't Promise, Don't Refuse
When an employee asks for a raise you can’t approve, don’t promise and don’t refuse. Say: “I can’t approve this myself. I can help you build the case, and I’ll take it to [the boss]. Let’s write it together.” Then tell them the questions your boss will ask, and coach them while they write the answers.
What usually happens when an employee asks for a raise?
Your best direct report says, “I’d like to discuss a raise.”
The budget isn’t yours to approve.
Sweating, you think, “Don’t promise them anything. Don’t lose them either.”
So you say, “Let me see what I can do.”
You take it upstairs. Your boss asks 3 questions you can’t answer.
Two weeks later, you tell your report:
“Budget’s tight this year.” They hear “no” and open LinkedIn that night on beast mode.
Why doesn’t “let me see what I can do” work?
“Let me see what I can do” put the raise on your shoulders. And you were never the one who could say yes.
What should you say to an employee asking for a raise?
So don’t promise, and don’t refuse.
Say this:
“I can’t approve this myself. I can help you build the case, and I’ll take it to [the boss]. Let’s write it together.”
What will your boss ask about the raise?
Then tell them what the boss will ask.
For example:
- “What are you doing now that wasn’t in the job when we set your pay?”
- “What will you own next year that you don’t own today?”
- “Why now, and not at the March review?”
Who does what once you’re on the same side?
Now you’re on the same side.
- They write it.
- You coach it.
- You carry it upstairs.
What if the raise doesn’t go through?
If it goes through, amazing.
If not, you’ve improved your relationship with your best report.
And people stay with managers they trust.
If you’re a leader with interviews coming up for your next role, I help you get ready for them:

