How to Not Sound Rehearsed in an Interview: Go Back to Take 1
How to not sound rehearsed in an interview: go back to your first take and stop adding to it. The version that bores you is the one they’ve never heard.
We’re practicing your opening answer for Thursday’s VP final round interview.
It now runs 3 minutes long.
Your first take was 63 seconds.
Somewhere around take 6, you got bored of telling the same story.
So each rep picks something up:
- A detail from your second job.
- A more dramatic phrase for the big win.
- A line about “why this company,” just in case.
You’re probing. Looking for the best answer. But also trying to sound natural.
Why does a rehearsed answer keep getting longer?
You’ve heard it 10 times. But the hiring team will hear it once.
By take 10, the answer feels stale to you.
It isn’t. You’re just tired of it.
So you keep decorating it to make it feel alive again, and a 63-second answer turns into a ramble.
Take 10 even has a callback to take 4. The panel has never heard take 4.
A big part of my job as an interview coach: getting smart people to say less.
How do you not sound rehearsed in an interview?
Go back to take 1.
When you first said it, it sounded scripted because you were reading it.
Now after all the practice, it will sound tight.
The version that bores you is the one they’ve never heard. And it’s the one that sounds most like you at your best.
If you’re a leader whose answers get longer the more you prep, this is what I fix:

