Failing Recruiter Screen Interviews? It May Be Your Attitude
If you’re annoyed about a phone screen interview, don’t try to fake being positive. Admit the annoyance to yourself before the call, so you don’t spend 15 minutes hiding-but-not-hiding it. Then treat the screen like one more application, and use it as practice.
What does annoyance look like on a recruiter screen?
Searching for a VP role.
You get a 15-minute screen with a recruiter who’s a decade junior to you.
“They already have my resume. Why do I need to be humiliated before talking to the hiring manager?”
You show up polite enough.
You give short answers.
You glance at your phone at minute 6.
You take a big sigh at minute 7.
Glance at your phone at minute 8.
You think you’re hiding the contempt, but you’re not.
The recruiter’s on her 9th call of the day, and she doesn’t especially care where this goes.
But she feels your annoyance, and that’s what she remembers.
Not your extensive experience.
As an interview coach, I’ve seen dozens of qualified people fail recruiter interviews. The easy interview. The “Just checking you’re not crazy” interview.
Isn’t the recruiter screen beneath you?
You’re right, your resume passed. You deserve a shot at the hiring manager. But this recruiter is not an insult.
They’re just a human, doing their job.
They are just as unhappy to do 30 screenings as you are to be screened.
Why can’t you just stay positive on the call?
Because you can’t force positivity out of yourself.
So admit it to yourself, before the call.
“I’m annoyed I have to do this. It’s humiliating.”
Once you’ve said it to yourself, you don’t have to spend the call hiding-but-not-hiding it.
How much should one phone screen interview matter?
The truth is, the recruiter may already have their pool picked.
They may have an internal hire. Your call may be a throwaway. You never know.
So treat it like one more application: spend 15 minutes, then forget it. Move on.
How do you use a recruiter screen as practice?
Use the 15 minutes as practice.
Talk about yourself to a live person. You usually have to pay for that practice. And the stakes are actually real now.
You get to practice handling the nerves too. It’s the same work I do with leaders preparing for interviews.
What should you do before your next recruiter call?
Here’s your invitation: write down what annoys you about the recruiter call.
Then decide what you’re going to practice on the call next time.
If you’re a leader who walks into the early rounds annoyed and the late rounds guarded, this is what I fix:

