Salary Negotiation After a Job Offer: Ask How They Got to the Number
When a job offer comes in lower than you hoped, don’t counter yet. Before any counter, ask how they got to the number: “Thank you, I’m excited about this. Can you walk me through how you arrived at that number?” Then stop talking. Their answer tells you where the room is.
What does salary negotiation after a job offer feel like?
The recruiter calls: “We’re thrilled to offer you the VP role. Base is $215,000.”
You were hoping for $240,000.
You think: “Don’t seem greedy. Just say thank you and sign.”
Then the other voice: “Counter at $250,000. Let them meet you in the middle.”
One feels like caving. The other feels like picking a fight with your future boss on day zero.
You hate the risk of burning a bridge before even crossing it.
What should you say first when the offer is lower than you hoped?
Before any counter, ask how they got to $215,000.
“Thank you, I’m excited about this. Can you walk me through how you arrived at that number?”
Then stop talking.
A big part of my job as an interview coach is getting smart people to say less.
What will they say, and what does each answer tell you?
Here are 3 answers you might hear, and what each one tells you:
1. “It’s the top of the band.”
The base is stuck. Ask about a signing bonus or a pay review at 6 months.
2. “It’s what our other VPs make.”
It’s about fairness inside. Ask what scope would put this role above theirs.
3. “It’s based on market rate.”
That one has room. For example:
“Ok. It’s a little surprising compared to the numbers I’ve seen in my research. I’d like to settle on something that works for everyone, so would it help to share what I found and compare sources?”
Why ask a question before you counter?
You can’t build a counter that fits their box until you know the box.
Nobody burns a bridge by asking a question.
What should you do before the offer call?
Before the call, write the question on a sticky note. Stick it on your laptop.
“Thank you, I’m excited about this. Can you walk me through how you arrived at that number?”
When they say the number, read it out loud and wait.
If you’re a leader with final rounds coming up, and the offer talk after them, this is what I help you prep:

